Can a man discipline his wife-Is Domestic Discipline Abuse or Loving Correction?

The domestic discipline DD movement encourages wife-spanking as discipline and is condoned and supported by some religions and religious leaders. But it's been argued that giving husbands this type of authority in a marriage can lead to spousal abuse and can destroy the self-esteem of the person being spanked. Here's a look at whether the practice borders on domestic abuse and constitutes violence, and whether it's scripture-based or sexually motivated. Domestic discipline, or Christian domestic discipline, is a submissive heterosexual marriage lifestyle that encourages husbands who are considered the head of the household or HoH to spank their wives for mistakes or misbehavior. There may be other methods of punishment used as well, including time-outs, loss of driving privileges, etc.

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife

It disxipline not life-giving to relationships. Therefore, women in general are called "nakedness". Muhammad said, "But for the woman, man would have entered paradise," Can a man discipline his wife and also, "Obeying them is [the cause of] their destruction. Disciplin women may believe DD gives them free rein to do what they want and being spanked or losing driving privileges eliminates the wrong. W omen I interviewed describe a hunger for submission that blends the spiritual with the profane.

Watching dvd on hard drive. Aeon Friends

It should siscipline firm and fair. One of the issues that has been raised is how can a man discipline his wife if the finances are tight? Maybe you put Can a man discipline his wife the purchase of that new dishwasher she has been wanting. My dad ditched us a long time ago. The sound of her cries got louder and louder. These are sins as husbands and wives that we must work on in our marriages. We sacrifice our faith, our obedience to God and the good of our families all in worship to these false gods. Free tour sexually explicite all that said I would not engage in wife spanking with my wife unless she came to a point where she accepted this as a God ordained method of discipline disciplone she does not. If your wife is spending too much discipliine online like Facebook or other social outlets or hs shopping then if she does not respond to your warnings about this you could change your internet code on your Can a man discipline his wife so that her devices will not have access to the internet. When I was younger and out of control.

Modern jurists and writers have done their best to weaken this verse by interpreting "rebelliousness" as disobedience and adultery, where beating would be the last means a man can resort to in order to keep the woman from committing that heinous deed.

  • Biblically speaking all those who are under various authorities can and should be disciplined by those authorities.
  • The husband is the leader and head of the home.

Modern jurists and writers have done their best to weaken this verse by interpreting "rebelliousness" as disobedience and adultery, where beating would be the last means a man can resort to in order to keep the woman from committing that heinous deed.

How excellent a servant he was! He was a penitent. Qatada narrated: "Job's wife disobeyed him. So the prophet of God Job swore that he would give her a hundred lashes if God healed him. This is because it was narrated that a man beat his wife during the lifetime of Muhammad, and her family wanted a requittal.

Beating should not be intense mubarrih , as the jurists proved from the hadith pertaining to the permissibility of beating women. He thanked God and praised him, and started preaching, saying, "I command you good-will for your wives, for they are captives to you that do not own anything, unless they commit a manifest obscenity [or adultery].

If they do [commit it], then God has given you permission to leave them alone in their beds and give them a bearable beating. There is still a difference of opinion, however, among scholars about the definition of "rebelliousness," which gives a man the right to resort to beating as a last means.

Some consider a woman's abstaining from ornaments, provided that the man wants it, as rebelliousness. They say, 'He may also beat her for neglecting her religious duties; such as ablution, praying It is stranger still that Muslim writers in the twentieth century try to justify this weird apology by the alleged discoveries of psychology in Europe.

Even though they scream No one should think that beating has a brutal aspect, as there are women who beat their husbands, and others do not allow their husbands to approach them [physically] except after they have given them a thrashing, to cause them to bleed.

This has been pointed out by psychological studies on perversion. If this is too much for their ethics, then their ethics have become refined to the point of nonexistence.

In fact, many of their western leaders beat their cultured, educated wives, whether dressed or naked. This has been practised by their wise men, scholars, kings, and princes, since it is a necessity that the majority of people cannot do without in honouring these educated women.

How then could a necessity in a general religion, which suits both rural and urban societies and all sorts of people, be condemned? This is a needful procedure when the environment and morals are corrupt. It is permitted when the woman's return from her rebelliousness depends on it.

But if the environment is good and women are receptive to advice and responsive to admonition, or give up [their evil ways] when deserted, then beating should be done away with. Each case has a judgment that suits it in the [Islamic] legislation, and, at any rate, we are instructed to be lenient and fair with women, and to retain them with decency or send them away with decency. The hadiths that speak of the instructions dealing with women are numerous.

Scholars are painstaking in emphasising that not all women should be beaten. There are women the majority who do not need to be disciplined by beating. This last point makes it impossible for a Muslim to reject beating utterly, so the Muslim is at a loss, not knowing how to defend or justify it.

He may justify it by the usage of beating as disciplinary punishment in the military and in schools, or compare beating with wars that keep order in the world!

There are others, still, who try to break with marital rights and try to lift themselves above the head of the house and reject the dictates of their own nature. Civilised Muslims have misunderstood this sort of remedy and described it as a dry desert-like remedy that doesn't suit civilisation, which demands that honour and respect be paid to the wife.

Islam was not intended for a certain generation, region, or environment. It is a guidance and a legislation to all generations, regions, and environments. In fact, physical punishment for deviates and perverts, who do not learn by exhortation or abandonment, is required by natural instinct and is determined by the social system.

Nature has handed this [practice] down from father to son, as it has handed it down among the nations to the rulers. But for it, no family or nation would live right. Physical wars, which are based on weapons of iron and fire between civilised nations at the present time, are only an example of this disciplinary punishment that awaits aggressors.

The divine laws perceive the phenomenon of war and fighting as follows: "If one of them should oppress the other, then fight the one who acts oppressively until they comply with God's commandment," and "If God did not defend [lit.

Such people pretend in their presence that they are keen on protecting women's honour and dignity, and on putting her on a level that displays her in an extraordinary way. He thinks it is right for a man to beat his wife when he is angry, to correct whatever mistake she makes. Yet, beating is permitted since some women accept discipline only through it. The objections to beating made on the part of modern-day pedantics should be treated as a skirmish in political manoeuvers, not as a real discussion of the affairs of life and morals.

There is only one consideration that validates the objection to beating as a punishment. Since God did not create women to be disciplined by beating, when nothing else seems to work. Anyone holding this view is oblivious to the fact that beating is approved as a disciplinary measure in the army and at school. So [this action is taken against] soldiers and pupils, whom we honour and respect, assuming the objection hinges on honour and respect. Al-Aqqad's thoughts concerning beating women can be summarised by this statement: There are some women among them that cannot be disciplined except by beating; and there are even some neurotics who crave beating just as some patients crave some sorts of torture.

The following is a quotation from the same author:. Women themselves may make fun of these babblers [he means women's rights activists] who are only at home at parties and in nightclubs.

Women know for sure that beating a disobedient and rebellious wife is not as appalling as it is claimed to be in the nightclubs and parties. They know, as others also do, that those women do not hate it [beating] or think it evil. It is ridiculous to imagine that there is no member of mankind who is not capable of being corrected by being beaten.

Or why don't those people object to the punishment of beating in the army? Muslims often repeat the hadith that says: "Paradise is under the feet of mothers," in order to prove the high position women enjoy in Islam. It is very hard to tell whether this tradition is true or not it has not been found in trustworthy writings. Yet, we have a number of Hadiths that occurred in the major acceptable books of hadith al-Sihah indicating that women are the smallest minority in paradise.

Give alms and ask pardon [from God] frequently, as I have seen that the majority of the dwellers of hell were you. Do you see anything?

If we take into consideration the hadiths concerning the dwellers of paradise the proportion of men to women will change drastically since they state that the dwellers of paradise will inherit their wives and concubines!

Abu Umama narrated: "The Messenger of God said, 'Everyone that God admits into paradise will be married to 72 wives; two of them are houris 9 and seventy of his inheritance of the [female] dwellers of hell. All of them will have libidinous sex organs and he will have an ever-erect penis. The sayings of Muhammad make it clear that the believer will be given special sexual power in paradise. Anas narrated: In paradise the believer will be given the power of such and such for intercourse.

The Messenger of God was asked, "Will he be able to bear that? Some scholars hold that there will be intercourse in paradise but there will be no giving birth to children. Ishaq Ibn Ibrahim narrates: "If a believer desires a child in paradise, he will have it at once, but he won't desire so. Another hadith says, "Men will enter into paradise after a short conversation with God.

They will go to their dwelling-places where their wives will welcome them. Their wives will ask them about the secret of their glamorous beauty which they did not possess before they left their dwelling-places. They will answer them, saying that they have sat down with their Lord, and therefore they have the right to it. So if Muhammad claims, in spite of the stories he related concerning the large number of wives and concubines in paradise, that women are the least among the dwellers of paradise, the reason would be that their men perished in hell because they were enticed by them [the women].

Muhammad said, "But for the woman, man would have entered paradise," 15 and also, "Obeying them is [the cause of] their destruction. And turn all together to God, O you believers; haply so you will prosper" Sura al-Nur Asma' said, "How ugly this is! He looked at a certain woman and she at him. Then the devil whispered to both of them that they looked at each other only because they liked one another.

The man kept walking alongside a wall, looking at her, and behold another wall hit him and his nose was split. The prophet said, 'This was the punishment for your guilt. One of the important terms in this verse is "nakedness", which is the genitalia. Therefore, women in general are called "nakedness".

The nakedness of a man with another man is between the navel and the knees. A man is not allowed to look at the nakedness of another man between the navel and the knees, but he is allowed to look at anything else. Muhammad said, "No man should look at the nakedness of another, and no woman should look at the nakedness of another. Malik said, "The thigh is not a nakedness. He said, "The Messenger of God sat at our place and my thigh was bare.

He said, 'Do you not know that the thigh is a nakedness? The nakedness of a woman with another woman is the same as the nakedness of a man with a man, namely from the navel to the knees, and it is permissible to look at anything else. This excludes the dsimmi and unbelieving woman who are treated in a different section later on.

If the man is closely related to the woman maharim , such as the father, the brother, the maternal and the paternal uncles, then his nakedness would be anything between the navel and the knee. And if he were a "stranger", his nakedness would also be the same as before. Yet another opinion says that all the body of man is nakedness, and that the woman ought not to look at it.

Inasmuch as he is not allowed to look at her, she is not allowed to look at him. But if the man is her husband, then there is no nakedness at all on the grounds of His saying: "Save from their wives and what their right hands own, then being not blameworthy.

Ahmad Ibn Hanbal has already stated this when he said, "Every part of the woman is a nakedness, even her fingernail. Malik and Abu Hanifa both hold that a woman's body is a nakedness, but for the face and the palms of the hands.

Each opinion has its own proofs which will be briefly listed later in the chapter. Zina is divided into two sorts: natural and acquired. As to the acquired zina ornament , it is the clothes, the beautifications, and the dyes that the woman puts on herself to improve her appearance. In this they hold that it is not permissible to look at the face of a woman for fear of temptation, since temptation caused by the face is greater than that caused by the feet, the hair, or the legs.

I say all this to say that in no way am I saying that you can completely ignore your wife as a form of discipline. But there are also deadbeat moms and in my life experience I have seen plenty of those as well. A wise husband should listen to wise counsel and that includes wise counsel from his wife. My best guess is that they wanted us to see and adapt their lifestyle as our way of life rather than us seeing it as odd or abuse. God commands older women to teach the younger women to love and obey their husbands. One wrong does not make another wrong right. I would never agree with a man going straight to these harder forms of discipline unless he has exhausted the gentler approach first.

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife. Постоянные читатели

.

Court rules on domestic discipline - The National

The domestic discipline DD movement encourages wife-spanking as discipline and is condoned and supported by some religions and religious leaders. But it's been argued that giving husbands this type of authority in a marriage can lead to spousal abuse and can destroy the self-esteem of the person being spanked. Here's a look at whether the practice borders on domestic abuse and constitutes violence, and whether it's scripture-based or sexually motivated.

Domestic discipline, or Christian domestic discipline, is a submissive heterosexual marriage lifestyle that encourages husbands who are considered the head of the household or HoH to spank their wives for mistakes or misbehavior.

There may be other methods of punishment used as well, including time-outs, loss of driving privileges, etc. Those who support the domestic discipline lifestyle give their reasons, which are often at odds with what research says about the practice.

Although defenders of domestic discipline believe that the DD lifestyle is based on Bible passages, some Christian religious leaders disagree.

Those who practice domestic discipline often mention scripture texts that call for a woman to be submissive to her husband, but there are many who follow a submissive marriage belief without beating or striking their wives.

A wise and Christ-honoring husband will not abuse his wife, which would include a physical altercation like spanking. Some believe that women want or agree with domestic discipline due to guilt over past sexual behavior, or because they believe that God has deemed that disciplinarian is the proper role of a husband.

DD is may be appealing to women who want to be free from having to make decisions or taking responsibility in life. Some women may believe DD gives them free rein to do what they want and being spanked or losing driving privileges eliminates the wrong. But according to some anti-DD Christian groups, the woman is relegated to child status with little motivation to grow into a "mature woman of God. Some women may deem these acts of discipline as acceptable or part of their subculture due to a history of sexual or physical abuse, notes Dr.

Others may find spanking sexually exciting. She adds that DD is a physical, mental, emotional, and possibly sexual safety risk of health and well-being. If you are in a domestic discipline marriage and are worried about the safety of yourself and your children, don't wait to get help.

Turning to a marriage or mental health counselor can help you break the silence and make an informed, rational decision about the health of your relationship. Learn the best ways to manage stress and negativity in your life. National Coalition Against Domestic Violence. What Supporters Say It comes from the Bible. It is not BDSM bondage, discipline, dominance, submission, sadomasochism. It is discipline; it is non-erotic. It is an essential part of the marital relationship. It provides a physical correction with one who truly cares.

It is responsible authority. It is appropriate punishment. It requires total consent from both parties. What Research Says It is based on misinterpretations of the Bible. It is a version of BDSM. It is sexually erotic. It is not life-giving to relationships. It is a control issue and is potentially abusive. Tension-building phase the build-up to domestic abuse Acute battering episode the spanking Honeymoon phase possible remorse, pursuit, and denial of the severity.

A Word From Verywell. Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback! Sign Up. What are your concerns? Article Sources. Continue Reading. Is Drinking a Cause of Domestic Abuse? Reasons Why Domestic Abuse Happens. Reasons Why Married People Cheat.

Verywell Mind uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using Verywell Mind, you accept our.

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife

Can a man discipline his wife